Maple vs Pine Flooring: Which Is Better for Your Home?

Both maple flooring and pine flooring are among the most popular types of wood flooring. Each can bring unique aesthetics and characteristics to your place. However, it’s often not easy for people to choose between these two for their homes. So, we’re going to discuss maple vs pine flooring from different aspects to help you make the right decision.

First, we need to know more about each of these wood floor species, then we can compare their qualities and discuss which can be a better option for your place. At the end of the article, we’ll answer some of your FAQs about maple and pine floors.

Minuteman Floors in Manchester, NH, offers professional installation and refinishing of high-quality maple and pine flooring.
Call now to discuss your project.

Hardwood Flooring Comparison: Maple vs Pine Flooring

While pine wood flooring is more commonly used in residential settings to bring warmth and coziness, maple is installed in both residential and high-traffic commercial spaces due to its resilience.

So, when it comes to commercial spaces, usually maple hardwood flooring is recommended but for a residential setting, you need to consider the maple vs pine flooring guide below to make the best decision for your home.

Everything You Should Know About Pine Wood Flooring

Pine flooring is known for its rustic and warm appearance and offers a range of color options to match any design.

The natural colors vary by pine species and can include shades from pale yellow to light cream and brown, often with a hint of reddish hue. If there isn’t any UV-protective finish, the pine wood turns darker and develops a patina, which can be attractive and enhance its warmth.

Additionally, there are variations in grain patterns. The grain in pine wood is usually pronounced and can be straight or wavy. Although the bold and irregular grain pattern can add visual interest, the most distinctive feature of pine flooring is its knots.

These unique knots can also vary in size, frequency, and color but they’re typically darker and add to the floor’s warmth, texture, and rustic appeal.

What’s more, pine can be stained to achieve darker colors for those who prefer dark brown, mahogany, gray, and other common stain colors.

You’d also be surprised to know pine can be painted to achieve white or bold colors which is a great option for customization.

However, there’s more to a floor than its look. Let’s dig deeper into pine flooring.

Pros and Cons of Pine Flooring

Advantages of pine wood flooring:

• It’s a cost-effective choice compared to oak and maple hardwood.

• A pine floor creates an inviting space and gives it a natural rustic look.

• It’s easy to customize because pine takes stain and even paints well.

• Pine is soft and feels comfortable underfoot.

• For those who like the appearance of aging wood, pine develops a rich patina over time.

• It’s a sustainable option because pine grows fast and is usually sourced from responsibly managed forests.

• Although it’s mostly famous for its rustic and natural appearance, it can fit different styles with the right choice of finish and species.

Disadvantages of pine flooring:

• Pine is usually considered as softwood which means more dents and scratches. That’s why it’s not recommended for places with heavy foot traffic and pets.

• While cleaning isn’t a challenge (sweeping and vacuuming), more frequent refinishing and repair (which isn’t very easy) are needed compared to harder wood species, like maple.

• Pine is vulnerable to moisture damage if not sealed and maintained properly.

• A UV-protecting finish is needed if you don’t wish the floor to darken over time.

• Its inconsistent and irregular knots and grain pattern may not be appealing to some people, particularly those who prefer a more contemporary design.

• Pine isn’t as durable as other common wood flooring, like oak and maple. So, it may not add high resale value to your home.

Types of Pine Flooring

There are different types and species of pine flooring. Some of them include:

• Southern yellow pine is perhaps the most common type of pine flooring and includes several species, like longleaf or heart pine, loblolly pine, and slash pine. These species are denser and harder than other pine species and their Janka hardness ratings range from 690 to 870 lbf (pounds-force).

• Eastern white pine is soft and prone to everyday wear and tear. This type of pine wood Janka hardness rating is approximately 380 lbf.

• Reclaimed pine flooring is sourced from old pine wood. It’s an environmentally friendly choice and a great option for those seeking an aged and natural wood appearance.

• Engineered pine wood flooring has a layered structure which offers better stability and resistance than a solid pine floor. The top layer is made of real pine wood but the lower layers are made of plywood or HDF (high-density fiberboard). This means an engineered pine floor can withstand changes in temperature and humidity levels better compared to solid pine flooring.

Overall, while pine flooring can add rustic charm to your place and make it cozy, warm, and comfortable, you should consider its susceptibility to damage and maintenance requirements before making up your mind.

Everything You Should Know About Maple Hardwood Flooring

Maple hardwood floor is known for its sleek, uniform, and clean appearance due to its light colors and subtle and fine grain pattern. That’s why it’s mostly used in modern and contemporary styles.

While its natural color is light creamy with a golden hue, maple can be stained to achieve a wide variety of colors, even as dark as walnut and cherry.

Darker stains can create a sense of tradition, luxury, and warmth as well as highlight the natural grain. On the other hand, gray and whitewashed finishes add more to its sleek appearance.

So, you don’t have to worry about matching colors and styles but you should know more about the pros and cons of installing maple flooring in your home and its different types.

Pros and Cons of Maple Flooring

Advantages of maple flooring:

• Hardness and durability

• Versatility in finishing and customization

• Aesthetic appeal and variety in design options

• Ease of maintenance

• Sustainability (It’s domestic and a renewable resource.)

• Long-term investment and adding value

Disadvantages of maple flooring:

• Its sensitivity to sunlight may lead to darkening or yellowing when exposed to UV.

• Achieving a uniform stain is challenging and needs professional skills and experience.

• The subtle and fine grain pattern might seem uninteresting and plain to some.

• Humidity and temperature changes can lead to cupping and warping, like any other hardwood flooring.

• It can cost more than some common types of hardwood, like oak and pine.

Types of Maple Wood Flooring

Maple flooring offers versatility not only in color but also in type.

• Hard maple or sugar maple flooring is exceptionally hard and durable which makes it perfect for high-traffic areas. This type of maple flooring hardness rating is around 1,450 lbf which shows its resistance to everyday wear and tear. Hard maple, with its uniform and sleek finish, is often the best choice for sports floors.

• Soft maple’s Janka hardness is approximately 950 lbf and is less resistant to wear compared to sugar maple but still a durable choice for residential spaces. Soft maple flooring includes maple species like bigleaf, silver, and red maple that usually come with a more pronounced grain pattern.

• Engineered maple flooring consists of a plywood or composite base layer with a real maple layer on top. This structure offers better stability which makes it perfect for areas with significant fluctuations in humidity and temperature levels.

To choose the best type for your place, consider the

• foot traffic,

• lighting (If the place doesn’t get a lot of light, go with lighter colors.),

• size of the room (Light colors make a room appear more spacious.),

• maintenance requirements (Darker colors show the dust and scratches more.),

• design and atmosphere (Darker stains create a warm and classic look. Also, more pronounced grains can add visual interest and character.).

Let’s Sum Up Maple vs Pine Flooring Comparison

A quick look at the table below gives you a good summary of the maple vs pine flooring types comparison.

Expert’s Opinion: Which Hardwood Flooring Is Best for Your Home?

Now, if

• your place gets higher foot traffic,

• there are young children and pets,

• you have a lot of heavy furniture,

• humidity and moisture are a risk,

• the style is modern, minimal, and contemporary,

you should definitely go with maple flooring.

On the other hand, if

• you’re looking for a cozy and comfortable floor,

• the style you desire is traditional and rustic,

• you wish to customize the color with paint,

• you don’t anticipate high foot traffic, impact, and a lot of daily wear,

• the risk of moisture and water damage is low,

you can opt for pine flooring for its affordability and unique look.

Still not sure? Don’t worry! Call us todayto schedule your free home visit. Our experts have all the answers.

FAQs: Maple vs Pine Flooring for Homes

You might find the answers to your questions about maple or pine floors below.

How To Choose Between Maple and Pine Hardwood Floors?

You should consider the requirements of the place and your preferences, such as foot traffic, style, budget, and maintenance.

Maple hardwood flooring is great for residential and commercial places with heavy foot traffic and a contemporary style of décor because of its durability, ease of maintenance, and uniform and sleek look. However, it can be costly. Although considering its lifespan and resistance to damage, you can see it as a long-term investment.

Pine wood floor is usually considered softwood and it’s prone to dents, scratches, and damage. That’s why it’s best for low-traffic homes or vacation homes where a charming rustic look is preferred. It’s also a more affordable option.

Can Maple and Pine Flooring Be Refinished?

Yes. Both maple and pine flooring can be refinished multiple times, however, it depends on the thickness of the boards. Pine flooring refinishing can typically happen 2 to 4 times, while maple hardwood flooring can usually be refinished 3 to 5 times. You should also remember that as maple is a hard species, it doesn’t get dents and deep scratches easily, which means less frequent need for refinishing.

Can I Install Maple or Pine Flooring in My Kitchen and Bathroom?

For the kitchen, both maple and pine flooring can be installed but they should be properly sealed and maintained to avoid water damage. However, for bathrooms, due to its high levels of moisture and risk of water damage, pine or maple hardwood isn’t recommended. You can go with engineered hardwood or any other water-resistant flooring materials, like tiles.

Oak, Maple, Pine, Birch; Best Hardwood Flooring Installation in Manchester, NH

Many of us cannot say no to the timeless beauty of a hardwood floor. We offer the best wood species for flooring, such as oak, pine, maple, and birch, in Manchester and its neighboring areas in New Hampshire.

We not only guarantee the quality of the materials but also great craftsmanship and professionalism. Call us at 603-782-1942 now for any hardwood flooring installation and refinishing services from the comfort of your home.